Why people ask
ADHD diagnoses have risen sharply in many countries, including New Zealand, and ADHD content is everywhere online. That has led to a fair question: is this a real condition, or ordinary distraction and restlessness being turned into a diagnosis?
The question got a lot of attention in August 2026, when the UK's Channel 4 broadcast The Great ADHD Myth?, presented by NHS psychiatrist Dr Max Pemberton. The programme looked at the rise in diagnoses, including a private assessment Pemberton sought himself, and he concluded ADHD was "a social construct, not a disorder of the brain".
How the documentary was received
- The Royal College of Psychiatrists issued a statement the following day. It said the College takes an evidence-based approach, warned that the way people talk about neurodevelopmental conditions matters, and said people with ADHD should have a personalised plan that may include lifestyle changes, organisational skills training, coaching, therapy or medicine.
- ADHD UK, a charity, complained to Ofcom, the UK media regulator. It said the social-construct claim was contradicted by ICD-11, DSM-5-TR, the UK's NICE guideline, the Royal College of Psychiatrists and the 2021 international consensus statement.
- Channel 4 defended the programme, saying there is considerable public debate about aspects of ADHD and that it was legitimate to explore it.
Some commentators welcomed the programme as a long-overdue challenge. Critics, including clinicians, said it risked leaving people with ADHD feeling delegitimised.
What the evidence says
It's in the international classifications. The World Health Organization's ICD-11 lists ADHD as code 6A05 among neurodevelopmental disorders, and the US DSM-5 does the same. See is ADHD a mental illness?
There's an international consensus. In 2021 the World Federation of ADHD published 208 conclusions about ADHD, each backed by a meta-analysis or a study with more than 2,000 participants. The authors, who included Julia Rucklidge of the University of Canterbury, said the aim was to challenge misconceptions that stigmatise people and delay treatment. It was endorsed by 366 people who read it.
It's strongly heritable. A 2019 review of 37 twin studies put the average heritability of ADHD at 74%. See is ADHD genetic?
It has measurable outcomes. A Danish study of 1.92 million people found people diagnosed with ADHD had about twice the death rate of people without it, mostly from accidents. Large studies also link it to lost work days, transport accidents and higher rates of anxiety and depression. See untreated ADHD.
Where the real debate is
The strongest scientific challenge isn't that ADHD doesn't exist. It's about where to draw the line, especially in children.
A 2021 Australian-led review in JAMA Network Open looked at 334 studies of ADHD in children and teenagers, using a framework for spotting overdiagnosis:
- 45 studies showed actual diagnosis had increased.
- 25 studies suggested the extra cases may be at the milder end of the spectrum.
- 83 studies showed treatment with medicine was increasing.
- Only 5 studies looked at whether those extra, milder cases benefited more than they were harmed.
The authors concluded there was evidence of overdiagnosis and overtreatment in children and adolescents, and called for better research on milder cases. They did not conclude ADHD isn't real.
Other legitimate concerns include:
- Symptoms sit on a spectrum. Everyone is distracted sometimes, so the cut-off matters, and two careful clinicians can disagree about borderline cases.
- Assessment quality varies. Quick or low-cost assessments that skip childhood history or other explanations can get it wrong in both directions.
- Other conditions look similar. Anxiety, depression, poor sleep, trauma and substance use can all cause ADHD-like symptoms.
Both can be true
ADHD is a real, well-studied condition that causes real harm when it's missed. It's also true that diagnosis can be done badly and that milder cases need careful judgement. The answer to both problems is the same: a thorough assessment against the diagnostic criteria, with evidence from childhood and other causes considered.
The New Zealand picture
In New Zealand the bigger problem for adults has been access, not excess. A 2024 New Zealand Medical Journal study found only about 0.56% of adults were dispensed ADHD treatment in 2022, well below the share estimated to have ADHD. The Royal New Zealand College of GPs' 2025 guidance asks for an in-depth clinical interview, evidence of childhood symptoms and consideration of other explanations, the safeguards that matter most in the overdiagnosis debate. See ADHD in New Zealand.
Make up your own mind about your symptoms
A screening test can't settle the debate, but it can tell you whether your experiences line up with the symptoms researchers study. The free 18-question adult ADHD test uses the World Health Organization's ASRS v1.1 and emails you your results. It is not a diagnosis.